Extra Creamy Classic Mac and Cheese

a close up of creamy mac and cheese in a bowl

I have no time for dry, crumbly mac and cheese-I want it rich and extra creamy or not at all (okay, I'd still eat it). But that classic mac and cheese you love with an extra creamy twist is what I have for you today. I've said it before and I'll say it again, I don't mess around with mac and cheese so you can trust me when I say it's good! This is the perfect mac and cheese recipe to serve your family when they're looking for comfort food and you want to make a vegetarian meal evvvveryone will enjoy.

PS. I know "extra creamy" is already in the name, but if you don't like lots of sauce for your mac and cheese, you might want to make more pasta so it isn't as saucy!

Jump to Recipe

How to Make Extra Creamy Mac and Cheese

By the way, if you like this mac and cheese recipe (or my other vegetarian comfort food recipes) and you'd like to buy me a coffee, here's the link to do so: https://buymeacoffee.com/xoandso. It is never expected, but always so appreciated. 

Here are some tips for getting a really creamy mac and cheese. 

Shred the cheese yourself

One of the key strategies for getting extra creamy mac and cheese is shredding the cheese yourself from the block rather than buying a bag of shredded cheese. This is a topic I'm pretty passionate about-but for good reason!

It genuinely makes a BIG difference in the overall quality and texture of your mac and cheese sauce.

That's because bags of shredded cheese have cellulose and other non-cheese ingredients, which help prevent it from clumping together in the bag. Unfortunately, these same ingredients also prevent the cheese from melting as smoothly into the sauce as it could.

Shredding your own cheese creates a much smoother texture to your sauce since all you're adding is pure cheese!

Plus, when you shred it yourself, you actually get a far better bang for your buck. More cheese for less money? Yes please!

So, the next time you make mac and cheese, remember this key step-it makes all the difference! Shredding your own cheese will ensure your mac and cheese comes out creamy every single time.

Use a mix of milk and cream (or just cream!)

I understand you might be tempted to use JUST 1 or 2% milk to make mac and cheese, but trust me-you won't regret using a mix of cream and/or half-and-half in its place.

It's actually not technically essential that you use cream; you can still get good results with just whole or 2% milk. But if you want the creamiest mac and cheese possible, opt for heavy cream, half-and-half, or a combination of the two. It'll add an extra richness to your sauce that's unbeatable.

Make a roux

A roux is a mix of fat and flour cooked until it thickens and can be used as a thickener for sauces. It's a French culinary technique, but it's perfect for mac and cheese!

It adds a great depth of flavor to the sauce!

To make a roux, start by melting butter in a pot over medium heat. Once melted, whisk in all-purpose flour until smooth (you may need to add more butter or flour to get the correct consistency). Cook for 1-2 minutes until slightly golden, and then whisk in your milk of choice. Once the sauce is thickened, add cheese and seasonings to finish off the sauce.

Use a combination of cheeses

Cheeses with a relatively low melting point are ideal for mac and cheese because they melt more easily into the sauce without getting stringy or grainy. Softer cheeses like cheddar, gouda, and sometimes even cream cheese will make your mac and cheese super creamy.

I also love using a combination of these cheeses to get a really rich and flavorful sauce. Try mixing cheddar with a sharp or smoked cheese for an extra kick of flavor, or adding cream cheese for a smooth finish.

Extra Creamy Classic Mac and Cheese

Here's what you'll need for my classic mac and cheese recipe!

(And again, this is an EXTRA CREAMY recipe. If you want it less saucy, you'll want to use more pasta.)

  • Macaroni noodles
  • Butter
  • All-purpose flour
  • Milk
  • Heavy cream or whipping cream
  • Sharp/old cheddar
  • Monterey jack cheese
  • Mustard powder
  • Onion powder
  • Garlic powder
  • Smoked paprika
  • Salt and pepper

📖 Recipe

Chelsea Kram – XO&So: Vegetarian Comfort Food

Extra Creamy Classic Mac and Cheese

4.90 from 19 votes
The ultimate classic mac and cheese recipe that's extra creamy, extra delicious, and extra comforting. It has two types of cheese and a super smooth, rich sauce you won't be able to get enough of.
REMINDER: This is an EXTRA CREAMY recipe. If you want it less saucy, you'll want to use more pasta.
By the way, if you like this mac and cheese recipe (or my other vegetarian comfort food recipes) and you'd like to buy me a coffee, here's the link to do so: https://buymeacoffee.com/xoandso. It is never expected, but always so appreciated. 
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Servings: 5
Course: Main Course
Calories: 989

Ingredients
  

  • 3 cups macaroni noodles measured dry
  • 5 tablespoon butter
  • 4 tablespoon all-purpose flour
  • 2.5 cups milk I use 2%
  • 1.5 cups heavy cream or whipping cream
  • 2.5 cups sharp cheddar shredded
  • 1 cup monterey jack shredded
  • ½ teaspoon mustard powder
  • ½ teaspoon garlic powder
  • ½ teaspoon onion powder
  • pinch of smoked paprika
  • salt and pepper, to taste I use at least ½ tsp. of salt

Method
 

  1. Boil the macaroni noodles in a large pot of salted water according to package instructions. Drain and set aside.
  2. In a large saucepan over medium heat, melt the butter. Add the flour and whisk to combine. Cook the mixture, whisking constantly, for 2-3 minutes until it becomes a light golden color.
  3. Gradually add the milk and heavy cream, whisking constantly to prevent lumps. Continue cooking the mixture, whisking frequently, until it thickens and comes to a simmer.
  4. Reduce the heat to low and stir in the grated cheddar and Monterey jack cheeses, mustard powder, onion powder, garlic powder, and smoked paprika. Stir until the cheese is fully melted and the sauce is smooth.
  5. Add salt and pepper to taste
  6. Add the cooked macaroni noodles to the cheese sauce and stir until the noodles are glossy and well-coated.
  7. Enjoy your extra creamy and cheesy mac and cheese!

Nutrition

Calories: 989kcalCarbohydrates: 61gProtein: 34gFat: 68gSaturated Fat: 41gPolyunsaturated Fat: 3gMonounsaturated Fat: 17gTrans Fat: 0.5gCholesterol: 202mgSodium: 577mgPotassium: 470mgFiber: 2gSugar: 10gVitamin A: 2337IUVitamin C: 0.5mgCalcium: 784mgIron: 1mg

Notes

Reheating instructions: If you reheat this mac and cheese in the microwave, it won't be quite as creamy as when you make it the first time. However, I find that heating it on the stove in a pot with a bit more milk/cream added helps you get a really creamy result!
This could serve 4-6 people or many more if you're just serving it as a side.

Tried this recipe?

Let us know how it was!

Love this classic mac and cheese?

Here are some other mac and cheese recipes to try next:

Other popular holiday recipes:

I can't wait to hear what you think of my mac and cheese-thanks so much for giving it a try!

XO,

Chelsea

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




33 Comments

  1. 5 stars
    The easiest Mac & cheese with plenty of creamy flavor! Plus, I followed the recipe to a T. This one is a definite hit in my house! Thank You for sharing!

  2. 5 stars
    The extra creamy Mac and cheese is fantastic! And the Boursin baked in pastry with red onion jam is really festive. My daughter is in Paris as a Fulbright scholar and her husband is here with our family in New York. He is Hindu, and a vegetarian. These dishes allow us to share our western traditions.

  3. My family said this was the best Mac and Cheese I've ever made. They all commented on how creamy it was.

    My daughter just got home from the hospital with their new baby and this was the perfect comfort food to bring to their home.

    1. Thanks so much for taking the time to leave a review! Congratulations on your new grandchild!

  4. 5 stars
    Taste and texture where fabulous— because I used medium shells instead of elbow macaroni, I think next time I will use either 4 cups of shells or reduce the milk by one cup — I will make again! Thanks!

  5. 5 stars
    This was the best Mac and cheese ever. I even had to leave out the heavy cream because I didn’t have any, and it was still delicious. Thank you for the recipe.

  6. 5 stars
    This was the best mac & cheese ever, I even had to leave out the heavy cream because I didn’t have any and it was still delicious. Thank you for sharing!

    1. I'm so glad to hear that! Thank you so much for taking the time to leave a review, Theresa!

    1. Of course! You just need to multiply the ingredients to adjust the serving size!

  7. 5 stars
    My son is very picky about his Mac and cheese, he does not like baked or a crust on his Mac and cheese. We gave this recipe a 10. It was creamy and flavorful. I used shells, no more velveta for my house. My son said this is the recipe for life.

  8. 5 stars
    This Mac and cheese turned out fantastic. Creamy!!!
    I froze left overs in muffin tins and then stored in ziploc. Just pop in the oven for a bit and yum!

  9. 5 stars
    Absolutely love this recipe! My son and husband love how creamy this is and I love the flavor of adding a bit of smoked paprika. I did not have enough sharp cheddar so substituted some gruyère & it was delicious.

    1. I'm so happy you liked it!!! I'd love to try it with gruyere next time. Thanks very much for taking the time to leave a review, Mary!

  10. I’m taking this to someone else’s house for a party. I’ve never made it before. Is a crockpot a better place to serve it from or should I use a 9- by 11 baking sheet?

    1. Do you mean just to transport it in? I think a crockpot-style dish would be easier to travel with than a baking sheet!

    1. Wow!!! I'm thrilled to hear that! Thank you so much for choosing my recipe and letting me know! I know there are a lot of mac and cheese recipes to choose from so that means a lot.

    1. Thanks so much for your message and review, Beth! That makes me so happy to hear 🙂

  11. 5 stars
    I made this with this recipe verbstim and it was AMAZING! I've been searching my whole 50 years of life for the perfect (not too dry) mac and cheese recipe and I've FINALLY made it! THANK YOU! Definite keeper! I'm gonna be a hit at a lot of picnics this summer!

    1. I'm so happy that you liked it!!!!! Thanks so much for taking the time to write this!

  12. 5 stars
    If I make this 2-3 hours before a party, what is the best reheat option? Just warm in the oven at 180 for a bit?

    1. I think that would work! You could reheat it on the stove top too; it's probably creamy enough that you won't need more milk, but you could add a splash more as you reheat it.

  13. 5 stars
    It’s pretty good, I’d double the spices add white pepper and reduce the liquid by one cup next time and I think I’d be great!

  14. 5 stars
    Haven't made it yet. But I am wondering if this can be made without the Monterey jack cheese? What would be substitutes? Thanks for your reply.